Current:Home > InvestSupreme Court upholds rejection of "Trump Too Small" trademark in free speech dispute -Wealth Evolution Experts
Supreme Court upholds rejection of "Trump Too Small" trademark in free speech dispute
View
Date:2025-04-22 10:31:16
Washington — The Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that U.S. Patent and Trademark Office didn't violate the First Amendment when it refused to register a trademark for the phrase "Trump Too Small," saying a federal law prohibiting trademarks that include other people's names does not run afoul of the Constitution.
The high court reversed a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which found that barring registration of "Trump Too Small" under a provision of federal trademark law unconstitutionally restricted free speech. The ruling rejects the effort from a California lawyer to trademark the phrase.
"The history and tradition of restricting trademarks containing names is sufficient to conclude that the names clause is compatible with the First Amendment," Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the majority.
The court ruled unanimously that the federal prohibition on trademarks that consist of a living person's name without their consent does not violate free speech rights and noted that its decision is a narrow one.
"The Lanham Act's names clause has deep roots in our legal tradition. Our courts have long recognized that trademarks containing names may be restricted," Thomas wrote. "And, these name restrictions served established principles. This history and tradition is sufficient to conclude that the names clause — a content-based, but viewpoint-neutral, trademark restriction — is compatible with the First Amendment."
Justice Amy Coney Barrett, as well as Justices Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, noted separately that while they agree as to the constitutionality of the so-called names clause, they disagree with some of Thomas' reasoning.
The "Trump Too Small" case
Known as Vidal v. Elster, the dispute stems from California lawyer Steve Elster's attempt to register the words "Trump Too Small" for use on shirts and hats with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in 2018. The phrase references an exchange between then-candidate Trump and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio during the 2016 race for the White House. Rubio, also a GOP presidential hopeful, jokingly claimed Trump had disproportionately small hands as a veiled insult to his anatomy, prompting Trump to defend his hand size during a televised presidential debate.
Elster said he wanted to register the mark to convey a political message about the former president, who is vying for the job again, and his "package" of policies.
An examining attorney with the Patent and Trademark Office declined Elster's application to register the mark, citing a provision of the Lanham Act that bars registration of a mark that consists of the name of a living person without their consent.
An internal appeal board upheld the rejection, noting that the mark includes Trump's name without his approval. But the Federal Circuit reversed, finding that the part of the Lanham Act relied upon by the Patent and Trademark Office was unconstitutional when it comes to marks that criticize a government official or public figure.
Elster's T-shirts bearing the phrase "Trump Too Small" are still available online for $24.99, even though his trademark application was refused.
The ruling from the Supreme Court joins a string of other First Amendment challenges to provisions of the Lanham Act, the main statute governing trademarks. The high court in 2017 struck down a section of the law that barred registration of disparaging marks and did the same for a provision prohibiting immoral or scandalous marks in 2019.
Melissa QuinnMelissa Quinn is a politics reporter for CBSNews.com. She has written for outlets including the Washington Examiner, Daily Signal and Alexandria Times. Melissa covers U.S. politics, with a focus on the Supreme Court and federal courts.
TwitterveryGood! (634)
Related
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Why Oscars Host Jimmy Kimmel Thinks Jo Koy Should Get a Golden Globes Do-Over
- Women's basketball conference tournaments: Tracking scores, schedules for top schools
- Baltimore to pay $275k in legal fees after trying to block far-right Catholic group’s 2021 rally
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- Olympic long jumper Davis-Woodhall sees new commitment lead to new color of medals -- gold
- Canadian town mourns ‘devastating loss’ of family killed in Nashville plane crash
- Panel says the next generation of online gambling will be more social, engaged and targeted
- Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
- Tennessee lawmakers advance bill to undo Memphis’ traffic stop reforms after Tyre Nichols death
Ranking
- This was the average Social Security benefit in 2004, and here's what it is now
- Automaker Rivian pauses construction of its $5 billion electric truck plant in Georgia
- Disney Channel Alum Bridgit Mendler Clarifies PhD Status While Noting Hard Choices Parents Need to Make
- LinkedIn users say they can't access site amid outage reports
- DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
- Kristin Cavallari Shares the Signs She Receives From Her Brother 8 Years After His Death
- NFL Network's Good Morning Football going on hiatus, will relaunch later this summer
- NBA announces the Phoenix Suns will host the 2027 All-Star game
Recommendation
'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
Are you moving? Don't forget your change of address. Here's how to easily swap info.
FDA says to throw away these 6 cinnamon products because they contain high levels of lead
College student Wyatt Gable defeats 10-term state Rep. George Cleveland in North Carolina primary
What were Tom Selleck's juicy final 'Blue Bloods' words in Reagan family
US fencers raise concerns about biased judging, impact on Paris Olympic team
Zac Efron and John Cena on their 'very natural' friendship, new comedy 'Ricky Stanicky'
Gunman in Maine's deadliest mass shooting, Robert Card, had significant evidence of brain injuries, analysis shows